Short answer
For the orchids most people grow at home, such as phalaenopsis, a single leaf is generally not expected to grow into a new plant. A leaf cut or pulled off the plant will usually shrivel and die, whether it is placed in water, moss or soil.
Why orchid leaves do not behave like succulent leaves
Plants such as African violets and some succulents can regenerate from a leaf because the leaf tissue can form new shoots and roots. Orchids do not typically work this way. New orchid growth comes from the crown, a node on a stem, or an eye on a pseudobulb. A leaf by itself does not carry those growing points.
What about the viral leaf-propagation videos?
Short videos show orchid leaves sitting in moss, garlic water, or other setups, with captions suggesting a new plant will appear. It is hard to verify these, and the usual authorities on orchid propagation, including the American Orchid Society, describe propagation through nodes, pseudobulbs, divisions and keikis rather than leaves. If you try it as an experiment, expect that it most likely will not work and do not use a healthy leaf from a plant you care about.
What to do with a leaf that fell off or was cut
- Check the plant first. A yellowing lower leaf that drops is often part of normal aging, but several leaves falling at once can point to watering or root problems.
- Do not treat the wound as propagation. If the leaf tore away leaving an open wound at the base, a dab of cinnamon or fungicide is a common precaution against rot.
- Compost the leaf. There is little reason to keep it.
When a “leaf” growth is actually a keiki
If a new leaf is appearing on a flower spike or on the stem, it may be a keiki rather than an ordinary leaf. A keiki is a small clone of the mother plant that produces its own leaves and roots. See orchid keikis for how to recognize one.
Methods that do work
- Keikis: when and how to remove and pot an orchid keiki
- Division of sympodial orchids: how to separate and divide orchid plants
- Back bulbs: orchid backbulb propagation
For an overview of all of these, see how to propagate orchids.